Caitlin Starr: Shredding Boundaries and Shaking Up Queer Indie Rock

Music, Genres & Queer Creativity with Caitlin Starr

We cross the globe to New York to meet alternative rock musician, multi-instrumentalist, and self-proclaimed Libra, Caitlin Starr. We chat about breaking free from genre labels (02:47), how love and heartbreak inspired her single “Will You Be My Girlfriend” (06:03), and what punk, jazz, and rebellion mean to her creative freedom. Three tracks from her latest EP “Speed Saves” feature throughout the show — get ready for a genre-defying ride!

Featured tracks:

Photo: Lauren Davis

If New York’s alternative rock scene could bottle its thunder and reverb, it might just sound like Caitlin Starr. On the latest episode of The Lotl Lounge, we caught up with Caitlin, a multitalented lead guitarist, songwriter, and classically trained jazz pianist, on the eve of her new EP, Speed Saves. We talked music, breaking rules, queer sexuality and identity, and learning to thrive in spaces that aren’t always built for you.

So, what does it mean to carve out your space in a scene that’s stacked against you? And what happens when you’ve trained in one world but your heart leads you somewhere else? Caitlin Starr’s story is a testament to refusing to fit the mould even when the path is bumpy, lonely, or paved with a little lesbian fuckboy drama.

From Classical Roots to Punk Grit

Caitlin’s musical journey started behind a piano. But it didn’t take long before the rigid world of classical and jazz training lost its shine. “I really never had the attention span to sit still and do classical,” she laughs, recalling her early days surrounded by sheet music and stern teachers. She fell for jazz, but found the scene tough: “It was very male-dominated, and I didn't love the kind of culture around it, it was very kind of competitive and it also kind of required that you would sit in front of the piano for like so many hours and transcribe and learn stuff.” 04:00

There’s both courage and honesty in letting go of what you’re good at, to chase what actually moves you. For Caitlin, the breakthrough came in California, where a chance friendship (that unfolded into a crush, naturally!) reignited her love of songwriting and introduced her to the electric guitar. “Then quarantine happened, and I just started, like, I couldn't stop writing songs. And I started playing electric guitar more and listening to like a lot of hardcore music.” 05:29

The result: a genre-defying style that balances punk edge and open-hearted indie, all driven by her sharp, playful musicianship and disruptor spirit.

Queer Love, Situationships & The “Lesbian Fuckboy”

Few write about queer love with Caitlin’s wit and lightness. Asked about her track “Will You Be My Girlfriend,” she admits, “I wrote it…when I was dating this lesbian fuckboy named Nicole.” 06:03 The term got a laugh “I’m sure your audience is familiar with them; it’s just like a fuckboy but lesbian version.” But there’s a core of something very real there: the endless dance between labels, identity, and yearning.

“It’s always like this funny dance with all these labels… one person wanting one thing and the other not wanting it. And it's always like really back and forth.” 06:53 The song captures that tug-of-war, that vulnerability we risk as queer folks trying to define our place, and each other’s, in a still-conservative world.


Making Room for Evolution

If there’s a thread that ties Caitlin’s journey together, it’s the refusal to get stuck in one box for her, genre-fluidity and identity go hand in hand. “The two EPs are not that different in style, even though this second one has definitely its own thing to it, and it’s the first time I’ve played piano on an EP, which is exciting. I think…my style keeps evolving. I don’t want to keep doing the same thing forever.” 07:25

In a world that often demands LGBTQI+ artists “represent” in fixed, palatable ways, artists like Caitlin remind us that queerness itself is built on transformation, contradiction, and breaking through boundaries set by someone else’s comfort.

Why Representation (and Revisiting the Archive) Still Matters

Music has the power to both reflect and redefine community. The Lotl Lounge has always championed the voices and stories, especially of women, non-binary, and queer artists that mainstream histories often forget. Caitlin fits right into that legacy as a musician pushing at edges and never quite settling.

When asked if she’d ever tour Australia, her enthusiasm was infectious: “Oh my goodness, I would love that. I hope this happens.” 08:09 For all of us here, longing to see the next generation of queer musicians on our stages, that’s a promise worth getting excited over.

Your Soundtrack for Rebellion (and Tenderness)

Three tracks from Speed Saves—“Cage,” “Piece of Clay,” and “Will You Be My Girlfriend”—anchored the episode, each one a study in contrasts: furious guitar riffs, then gently melodic lines; lyrics that teeter between riot and romantic mess. Loud, fierce, and unapologetic, Caitlin’s music is about hiding from nothing: not heartbreak, not anger, not queer desire, not the messy “in-between.”

As you listen, consider the power in simply showing up as yourself, in all your contradictions, your shifting genres, your evolving labels. There’s revolution in that. And for every girl who learned the wrong instrument, who was told to sit still, to pick a lane, Caitlin Starr’s work is a shot of un-cut, glittering possibility.

Follow Caitlin’s Journey

You can stream Caitlin Starr’s latest EP Speed Saves, connect on social media, and (hopefully soon) catch her live on an Australian stage. Let’s keep building this community—across oceans, across genres, across every “should” and “should not.”

Turn it up loud, and claim your space.

Find more interviews with inspiring queer artists by following the Lotl Lounge on your favourite podcast app, and never miss a beat from Australia’s LGBTQI+ creative scene.

Previous
Previous

Lavender In Queer History: The Plant, The Colour, The Legacy

Next
Next

Behind the Curtain with the Fuccbois